Almost No Reduction in Buy To Let Supply, insists think tank

There’s been at most a one per cent reduction in landlords in the buy to let sector, a think tank claims today.

The Resolution Foundation claims rent levels for new tenancies have grown by an average 18 per cent since January 2022. The think tank claims this has had a big effect on families’ living standards, with the number of families privately renting almost doubling in a generation – from 11 per cent in the late 1990s to nearly 20 per cent today.

Private renting is also no longer the preserve of those in their 20s. The proportion of poorer families headed by someone aged 30-49 that are renting has almost tripled from just 11 per cent in the mid-1990s to nearly 30 per cent in 2021-22.

The Foundation says that popular arguments on what causes rent rises are wide of the mark. 

It says the theory that rising interest rates have pushed up the cost of servicing Buy to Let mortgages – forcing landlords to pass on these costs to their tenants – ignores the fact that landlords’ ability to pass on higher costs is ultimately constrained by the wider rental market. If it were so easy for landlords to unilaterally choose to increase rents, they would likely have done so before 2022, says the foundation.

It adds there have also been what it calls ”scare stories about interest rate rises and tougher regulation sparking a mass exodus of landlords from the private rental sector, reducing the supply of available homes.” It says this isn’t true, and claims its analysis of Bank of England research shows that there has only been a very modest shrinking of the PRS since mid-2019, equivalent to just one per cent of the sector.

Instead, the foundation says, the main causes of Britain’s private rents surge is a bounce-back from the pandemic and more recently fast rising wages. The foundation notes that rents tend to track wages over the long-term – and that average private rents have remained roughly constant as a proportion of average earnings since 2000.

However, the disruption caused to the rental market by the pandemic, during which evictions and repossessions were halted, meant that rent levels fell to their lowest level on record relative to earnings, and, by early 2022, were nearly 5 per cent lower than what a long-term trend would suggest. Some of the recent surge in rental prices is therefore a post-pandemic ‘correction’, returning the UK’s rent-to-earnings ratio to its long-term trend.

This post-pandemic catch-up has been compounded by historically high nominal earnings growth in recent years, with average earnings rising by 13 per cent since the beginning of 2022.

But it says that with that ‘catch-up’ now done and pay growth cooling, the surge in rents for new tenancies should come to a close. In fact, market rents for new tenancies have already begun to cool, falling from annual growth of 10.4 per cent in June 2023, to 7.5 per cent by March 2024.

However, the Foundation warns that although growth in rent levels for new tenancies is cooling, it could take years for the burst of growth we’ve seen to make its way through the whole private rental sector. New renters will pay these new higher rents, while existing tenants reaching the end of a tenancy or forced to accept within-tenancy price rises, will in future face large rent hikes, equivalent to around 13 per cent in the next three years.

A spokesperson for the foundation says: “Millions of families agreeing new tenancies across Britain have faced surging rents in recent years, as we have emerged from the pandemic. Those rises for new tenancies are starting to slow, but how much renters actually pay will continue to outgrow how much they earn for some years to come as those not yet exposed to higher prices are hit.

“With more families renting privately, and renting for longer too, these rent surges are a bigger problem for Britain, and require bolder solutions from policy makers. Short-term solutions include regular uprating of Local Housing Allowance to support poorer families, and the ultimate longer-term solution is to simply build more homes.”